Delivered by Shippit

From one-off shoppers to regulars

Published 19/11/2026

How to keep the customers you win on Black Friday

Subscribe to Delivered.

Black Friday is eight days away. 

Despite strong economic headwinds, highlighted by the fifth interest rate rise of the year earlier this month, Australians are still gearing up to spend big. 

Shoppers are forecast to spend a record $7.2 billion over the Black Friday Cyber Monday weekend, according to Australian Retail Council (ARC) and Roy Morgan research. 

Delivery networks are already in overdrive, with 10% more orders on Shippit during the opening weeks of peak compared to the same period last year.  

If your sale goes to plan, you’ll see a wave of new names in your order list. Many will be first-time shoppers who completed a purchase solely because of the discount you offered. 

That’s a welcome ‘sugar hit’. But sugar hits don’t last. Not all, but many of those shoppers came for the price, not the brand. Bringing them back without another sale is a tall order.

So how do you turn a one-off sale shopper into a repeat customer? 

In this edition of Delivered, we look at why Black Friday customers drift away and what you can do to turn them from a one-off shopper to a loyal customer.

TL;DR

  • Black Friday is forecast to break records but there’s a January cliff edge, and the customers you win with discounts are 30% less likely to buy again.
  • The discount gets them to checkout. The delivery, meanwhile, decides whether they ever reach it again.

The January cliff edge

All the signs point to a strong November, but the customers driving it are also the least likely to return. 

Internationally, 13.95% of new shoppers during Black Friday make another purchase within six months, according to an analysis by Tresl Segments. However, 19.2% of new customers during the rest of the year make a repeat purchase within six months. 

That means Black Friday shoppers are about 30% less likely to turn into repeat customers. 

Why? Many were drawn to the ‘SALE’ banner rather than the brand name next to it. That means there’s no relationship to bring them back with. And if they’re trained to wait for deals, they’re loyal to the brands that win the race to the bottom. 

They’re also more expensive to win, and not just because of the margin you sacrifice slapping a 40% discount on your stock. Because more brands are competing for attention, advertising costs can typically run 29% to 46% higher during the Black Friday window than the week prior. 

Costlier to win and harder to retain isn’t conducive to growth. And that matters more than ever this year. 

Defaulted payments, 60+ day arrears, and tax defaults have all jumped sharply for retailers, setting up a potential ‘January cash-flow squeeze’ after a bumper November, according to CreditorWatch’s latest Business Risk Index. 

“Black Friday will deliver strong sales for many retailers, but sales aren’t the same as cash flow,” says Patrick Coghlan, CEO of CreditorWatch. “The real test comes in January, when supplier bills for November stock fall due.”

Retaining the customers you win during Black Friday is one of the best ways through it. A one-off sale shopper contributes to a much-needed November spike, but a customer who returns at full price in January or February carries you through the quieter months - and they’re even more critical. 

What gyms know about January

Gyms face the same problem every year. January brings a rush of New Year sign-ups, but many of those members quickly fall by the wayside. 

Most members who quit do so in the first 90 days. Their motivation fades and the resolution they set fades before their intended habit has formed.

That’s why many gyms run a very deliberate first 90 days including, for example, a proper induction, a check-in after week one, and a ‘habit anchor’ like a standing class booking.

A Black Friday customer is your January gym member. The sale got them through the door, but what happens next decides whether they return.

Delivery is your loyalty program

For a first-time Black Friday shopper, everything about your brand, so far, has revolved around price. They saw a sale banner, filled their cart, and paid. 

What follows is the delivery. The dispatch notification, the tracking updates, and the parcel that arrives on the doorstep before, on, or after the promised date. That’s the first time they experience your brand on anything other than a discount. 

Delivery drives acquisition and retention. During Black Friday 2025, retailers offering same-day delivery grew 3.5% faster than those that didn’t, and those offering next-day delivery grew 4% faster, according to Shippit data. And it influences whether they come back or not.

Just 7% of consumers say they don’t have strong delivery expectations, and 68% might not return after a poor delivery experience, according to Shippit’s State of Shipping research. 

“Those that fail to meet these expectations may not feel their brand eroding today, but they risk long-term erosion of lifetime customer value as younger consumers consolidate their loyalty around the few brands that consistently deliver frictionless experiences.”

Rob Hango-Zada, Co-Founder and Joint CEO, Shippit 

That delivery is where their trust is won or lost. It’s what helps them decide where to shop for that last-minute Christmas gift, for the food that will stop Nala barking, or for materials for the school project that was dropped at 24 hours’ notice.

“For established retailers, loyalty programs are one of the biggest drivers of repeat purchases,” Rob continues. “In 2026, fast, reliable, and smart delivery is your ultimate loyalty program.”

Retailers getting this right aren’t treating delivery as a cost to squash. Rather than looking at the margin on each order, they’re treating delivery as a tool for acquisition and retention. “How much does this delivery cost?” becomes “How much is this customer worth?”

How to turn one-off shoppers into loyal customers

If your sale generated the first order, here’s how to secure the second, third, and fourth. 

  • Let tracking do the talking: Delivery anxiety is real, so overcommunicate. Branded tracking pages and automated updates keep customers informed from the moment they place an order. If a parcel runs late, the customer hears it from you before they realise it themselves. A delay they hear about from you feels like a high-touch service, whereas one they discover themselves feels like neglect.
  • Be ready for “where’s my order?”: Even with good tracking, some shoppers will get in touch. A quick resolution or helpful answer leaves a good impression. Silence or an unclear response gives no incentive for them to shop your brand again.
  • Segment your Black Friday shoppers: When the sale ends, identify and segment your first-time buyers. When the time is right (after, not before, their delivery lands) incentivise the next purchase. For example, promote your ‘by Christmas’ delivery cut-offs, a customer testimonial on your best-seller, or the new product range that’s landing in January.
  • Delivery options that keep them coming back: When asked what influences their purchase decisions at checkout, 40% of shoppers said cost-effective delivery and 34% said fast delivery options. Nearly two in three are happy to pay more for faster delivery, so give them the fast and affordable options to close the follow-up sale.
  • A promise they can trust: More than half (52%) of shoppers say a clear, reliable delivery date is essential, and 38% say an accurate date makes them more likely to buy. A precise date at checkout improves conversions two, three and four. Whereas a vague window gives them reason to hesitate.
  • Measure your retention: Track how many of your Black Friday customers buy again by the end of February. That number is every bit as important, if not more so, than whatever you presented to the board at the end of the sales campaign.

“The retailers and carriers who understand that delivery is where loyalty is won or lost (then invest accordingly) are the ones who will define what Australian retail looks like in the years ahead,” Rob adds.

If this edition of Delivered made you think about loyalty and LTV, share it with the logistics and ecommerce leaders in your network.

Past editions

Find more articles, news and insights

The Christmas cut-off
Blog

The Christmas cut-off

The Christmas cut-off
Value versus discounts
Blog

Value versus discounts

Value versus discounts
Peak is here, is your operation ready?
Blog

Peak is here, is your operation ready?

Peak is here, is your operation ready?
Solving Australia's driver shortage
Blog

Solving Australia's driver shortage

Solving Australia's driver shortage
Can you recover from a delisting?
Blog

Can you recover from a delisting?

Can you recover from a delisting?